The hostess was able to seat us without a reservation which was nice. The staff are very well trained. The food was good, they had vegetarian options which we liked but the portions could be a bit bigger for the price they charge. That one stuffed pepper was like 30 bucks.

Excellent food. Three in our party had different dishes and everyone loved their food. I had the Chicken Alfredo and it was at the top of the best I've ever had. The desserts were good, but on par with other good Italian restaurants. The only down side to this place is we were there for almost two hours from sit down to leave. We were prompt in ordering and asked for our check with the dessert to expedite things. Maybe this is just Island life. 😆 The food is fresh and amazing, just prepare to wait. Oh, and parking is a nightmare, so a cab is recommended.

Amazing food. We saw online that Mondays are $20 pasta entrees and they did not disappoint. Even the bread was to die for! The drinks are well made and quickly refreshed.

Our best meal on St Thomas. The service was top notch by Richie. THANKS. Home made pasta. The cioppino was great. Nice spice and added a side of linguine. Service and atmosphere were much more than we expected. See you soon.

The atmosphere was nice, clean, neat and casual. My family and I went for dinner for the first time and was beyond happy. Appetizers were fantastic, drinks were delicious and our entrées were all around perfection. Over all was happily suprised with everything including the fact that they had a simple chicken nuggets and fries (since my son is extremely picky and has been hard to find). All of the staff we encountered was very friendly including our waiter who was very knowledgeable to any questions we had. Also a surprising side note, the money spent on this bill was as much as we've spent eating at a short order beach-side restaurant (but the quality and taste was 1000 times better!)

One of my favorite dinner spots. Great pasta, great drinks and very good service. Mondays are pasta nights where you can get a fabulous entree for around $20 but honestly their normal menu prices are very fair. All pasta is homemade. Mussel appetizer was fabulous!!!

This place is a nice restaurant, but there is no organization. Let's wait 30 minutes for a beer, we could see the drinks we ordered at the bar, waiting for 20 minutes and no one taking them We waited 45 minutes for an extra slice of bread. We were celebrating a friend's birthday, when she went to the bathroom I told the waitress to sing her birthday, and she completely forgot In total a dinner for 3 people, we spent 3.5 hours.

We had the shrimp scampi, and pasta carbonara. I was not expecting it to be this good! Everyone raved about it and it delivered!! This was probably our favorite meal on our vacation! The pasta is homemade every day. The drinks were great as well! The staff were attentive and friendly! You won’t be disappointed!

Did I expect to get great Italian food on a Caribbean island? No. Did I get great Italian food on St Thomas? Absolutely! The muscles in the garlic cream sauce alone are worth the visit. The carbonara was fantastic and I really enjoyed the salmon a la Toscana.

My wife and I just got back from our honeymoon in St. Thomas, and we went to Pesce two different nights. Both times were amazing! The chicken parm, and Shrimp Scampi were top notch. The service was always on point and the bread (can't remember the name) was a great starter. Highly recommend!

My husband and I went here 2nd night in St. Thomas and it was phenomenal!! We have spent time in Italy and can tell you these pasta dishes were amazing and most definitely fresh and homemade!! The lava cake for dessert was sincerely the best I’ve ever had!! It isn’t cheap, but it was well worth it compared to Easterly where we ate the night before. It’s all indoor and air conditioned too which is nice and not the norm for the area!

Fast delightful service with delicious fresh pasta! Highly recommend making reservations however, so plan accordingly. Well worth the reservation!

The food is so incredibly fresh and delicious, authentic and perfectly seasoned, the wines are paired perfectly with what you want, the dessert was worth all the calories you didn’t need but had to have and the service… I haven’t seen service like this in years! We’re still talking about how well we were treated from the time we walked in until the moment we left. I’m so grateful we found this gem and we definitely #enjoyed our time, eating authentic Italian food, sipping wine and listening to Frank Sinatra in the background! I personally felt like I was Julia Robert in Eat, Pray, Love. I ate like I hadn’t eaten in a while, I prayed and thanked God for all the love that surrounds me every day and I loved this little place! One of my all time favorites. Hope it’s yours too ❤️🥰💃🏻🎶🐉

Make a reservation! We didn’t, but luckily for us it’s the slow season and they bent over backwards to accommodate us. We had the best server in the joint who we’ve now adopted into our family. The drinks were delicious, the appetizers so tasty, and we were all nearly 100% satisfied with our food. Photos don’t do it justice because of low lighting.

The place is nice and staff were really welcoming, but the food was not good. We ordered the flat bread and they put WAY too much garlic on it I could not taste anything else besides the garlic ( it was supposed to be a margharita )…also the appetizer that we ordered was a little spicy which they didn’t specify on the menu. I won’t come back for flat bread again but I might give them a second chance for something different . 😀

This restaurant was only a few feet from our condo so super convenient. It definitely wasn’t the best meal we had on the island, especially for the price. The service was adequate. Their appetizers are really good. They have a different take on key lime pie.

Nice location right on the beach front. Lots of outdoor and indoor seating. Nicely sized full bar. Found atmosphere and overall lighting pleasing. We found the food to be good but not great. Noodles not fully cooked and fish was under salted and on the bland side. Crab cakes are nice but on the fishy tasting side. The pork chop was well cooked and juicy. Good option for a nice dinner.

Great spot for brunch, single , couple, groups , or families. I recommend making a reservations as this is a very popular spot. The ambience was perfect, situated right on the beach however open air seating us optional. Parking can be a small challenge during peak time. Our waitress was the perfect representation of hospitality. The food was delicious! My only complaint were the Hush Puppies, they seemed prefab, overcooked and extremely hard, other than that our food options were all delightful! I will definitely be back.

Outstanding restaurant. My wife and I are staying at the Ritz Carlton next door. We went down to the on site Italian restaurant and we were told that there wasn’t any table available but we could order take out. I decided that I want to have a nice sit down dinner with my wife so we came over to the Caribbean Fish Market. What a great choice. We started with the poke tune nachos and calimari. Both were excellent with a very slight sweet taste on the calamari that balances with the saltiness. My wife ordered the butter broiled lobster, and I ordered the catch of the day which was red snapper. Both were perfectly cooked. I highly recommend this restaurant. Especially if you are staying the Ritz and you don’t want to deal with their lack of service.

I have to say this was one of the best meals I have ever had. Everything was perfect, from the atmosphere, service, food and the view was incredible. I had the stuffed Caribbean Lobster and my husband had the prime rib which was delicious. For desert coconut cake and key Lime pie that melted in your mouth. They also have a red velvet bundt cake that my daughter loved and ordered multiple times. This was a perfect night in the Caribbean. Until next time St. Thomas.

Best seafood EVER! Seriously best I’ve ever had. We had tamarind calamari to start, entrees were grouper and sea bass, then shared key lime pie and ice cream sandwich for dessert. They make everything fresh even the ice cream! The attention to detail crafting each dish really showcases the love they have for the food. The service and the vibe was amazing. My husband almost fell asleep on the couches there. 🤣

A beautiful spot on St Thomas's east side. The food was very tasty, excellent wine selection and delicious ice cream made on site. Friendly staff, a little pricey.

We have been waiting 3 years to come back, and Caribbean Fish Market still holds up! In 2019, I claimed this as the best steak I’d ever had and in 2022, it’s still true. The filet is tender and fantastically seasoned and seared. My husband had rave reviews of his steak and lobster as well. My tequila sunrise was perfect. And of course, the view and ambience is lovely - lighted torches giving the and a pink tint and the calm ocean just a few yards from the table. Our server was very friendly, as were the hosts. The “good vibes only” photo setup in the back is a nice touch. Without a doubt, our favorite place on the island.

Our dinner here was our best meal of our trip to St Thomas, and that’s high praise considering some of the other amazing meals we had. The Caribbean Fish Market is Tucked away in the quiet and serene Elysian Beach Resort, with ample parking steps from the restaurant, we sat outside right off the beach and water, just a short drive from Red Hook. The food was absolutely delicious and was impeccably prepared, beautifully presented, and served by friendly and knowledgeable staff. I can’t wait to return!

Great food!! Well seasoned and the service was top notch. I went to Pangea, Easterly and now Caribbean Fish Market and hands down this was the best restaurant thus far. The Ambassador was our server on my first visit (he was AMAZING). We came back the next night and that server (not sure his name) was not as good. However, the manager took care of us and she's always there making sure things are proper. Awesome food again but we didn't care for the mussels. The recipe of spinach, bacon and mussels just wasn't appetizing to any of us at the table. Pictured shared is Chilean Sea Bass and Arugula watermelon salad. I took these pictures after tasting the food because it was worthy.

Wow! What a great restaurant. The food was freash, hot, and delicious. Our server was amazing, always checking on you and making sure your drink was full. The view was beautiful.

This place is right on Cowpet bay and it has a beautiful view with a breeze right off of the ocean. It is very well decorated and classy. It’s very pricey but to be expected for an upscale place. The food was quite good and so was the service. Would recommend for a special date night or birthday dinner.

THE BEST RESTAURANT ON THE ENTIRE ISLAND!! Ask for the Ambassador! He’s the best waiter, remembered us and our drink orders from before, great sense of humor and knows everything about the menu! The food and drinks were perfection with a fun, lively atmosphere to match. The local lobster with a shrimp topping was my favorite and my husband loved his tomahawk. My son LOVED his steak! Make a reservation and make sure you eat here!

One of the better restaurant for a good meal on the island. The atmosphere is very nice, the bar is lively and open air dining is nice. The staff and attitude can vary and that is the only downside.

Arrived in St. Thomas and came for dinner the first night. Food was fantastic and our server, Sean, was so kind and took great care of us. We ordered a sampling of appetizers and then my son got the crab encrusted whole lobster. Wow!! We ate too much and were sad to miss the homemade desserts but will be back.

The food here is top notch! My family and I had several options from the snapper to the stuffed lobster, and the salmon. All I can say is WOW! The location is stunning! Beautifully decorated. The staff are so professional and friendly! This is a great spot for date night or special evening! You will NOT be disappointed!

Unique style pizza. The crust was really good. The toppings and sauce were perfectly portioned. The bartenders were super friendly. Great service.

Ordered pizza to go. The menu had been downsized so if you are looking at the menu pics others had, keep in mind its the smaller one. It was good pizza. I had the Buffalo Chicken Pizza. I never had celery on a pizza before but it worked in this case. We also ordered a meat pizza also pictured. I included pics from our order.

We were looking for a place to eat after spending the day beach hopping on St. John's. Since we already had a vehicle parked at the ferry terminal lot (paid for the parking there) we figured we'd try a nearby eatery. We read some of the reviews and Island Time Pub was among the highest rated. We arrived during happy hour and enjoyed a couple beers with the pizza we ordered. The waitress was very friendly and was prompt with our drinks and food order and even agreed to take a photo of us with the marina in the background. The pizza was good, honestly nothing special, but the friendly service and beautiful setting overlooking the marina was what really set Island Time Pub apart. We'll definitely eat there again. Thanks again to the blonde waitress that waited on us.

Beach Life beers, incredible pizza and food, and locals chatting about their day at sea. This place is a wonderful respite from the hustle and bustle (if you can call it that) of Red Hook. Every once in a while a tarpon would roll on the surface while pelicans and gulls floated overhead. Great views of the marina and cool breezes kissed our salty skin. Excellent service in a spectacular atmosphere. Don't miss this place.

Fantastic pizza! Cold beer. On the water with nice views and a breeze. Bartenders were efficient and polite. Will definitely be going back the the pizza!

If you are looking for something different try the shrimp scampi pizza. Meatball pizza, uncle Vinnies, and chicken Alfredo were all a hit.

Covered outdoor 3rd floor bar food establishment. We walked through and decided to go elsewhere. Nice but just wasn’t what we wanted tonight.

We were told to go here for the pizza and they did not disappoint! ITP was our favorite low-key spot while in St. Thomas. Ended up here three times and the food was great each time. Two of the times we took it to go but the third, we hung out and enjoyed the atmosphere around the bar area. Fun spot!

I believe our server was Sabrina (sorry not 100% sure). What a character, she could hold her own with anyone. She was very helpful, funny and totally in charge, which she will tell you. We had the pizza as this was a last minute decision to eat here and so glad we did. Outside dining, view of the marina and very good pizza. Much larger than I expected, she suggested the guy version (rather told me I will get) with added pepperoni. It was loaded with leftovers to boot.

Y’all are awesome! Everyone. Grace really takes away from that! She is very selective. She ignored us to the point we had to keep calling Tommy to come help. Trying to order food was close to impossible because she literally was turning “the deaf ear”. Then to hear talk bad about people calling to order food only reinforced all of our feelings we felt about our own service. We have been there multiple times. We are not random visitors. She is the only reason for my 2 star overall rating.

Superb pizza, great combinations of toppings. The thin crust is interesting- the best of the more substantial thins ever. Service is quick and friendly. Prices reasonable. Great views, but watch out for the wind taking your paper plates and napkins! It’s overlooking the ocean after all.

1st time visiting, not a bad spot. 5 of us were seated didn't have to wait long. I would recommend the Spring Rolls for appetizer and the Mango Salmon Tango for lunch. The only disappointment was the "metal straw," which you had to buy to drink. While I get limiting use of plastics for environmental purposes, I would think that the choice would at least be given to adults. A good place to go nonetheless, would recommend and plan on visiting again

**Please give a like if this review helps😁😁** Food was good and convenient since i stayed on the property. I think the prices were typical for resort prices. Service was pretty good, nothing spectacular. The views of the bay were awesome and definitely gave the place a boost in atmosphere.

Two words: happy hour! We went every day we were there. 🤪 🍹⛱️ Great views and bartenders were super awesome and speedy. If we come back this will definitely be our spot again. CHEERS!

My NOW husband and I enjoyed this place very much! The waitress Jelly was so nice! We were seated outside to enjoy the BEAUTIFUL weather and hear the sounds of the waves crashing on the shore ❤️❤️🏝⛱️ 🌊! We loved our food and drinks!! we are on our honeymoon until Sat. and I have a good feeling we'll be here again! 😁😁☀️🏝🌊😋😋

Amazing views and atmosphere here! The bar overlooks the cays. Been here a week at the resort and ate here multiple times, Food is the typical hit or miss throughout the week, and far more consistent on the weekends. The bartenders friendly and the prices fair . Good spot ! Recommend the turkey club!

Probably one of the best experiences of my life to date. The locals people were very receptive and the food was outstanding.

Once COVID protocol is followed, guests and visitors can participate in many activities hosted by and through the property. There are areas for guests only but basic facilities visitors can access for their convenience as well. The views are amazing. The grounds are pristine and there is a lot to do. The restaurants offer terrific food and the bars that also serve food, have some of the friendliest bartenders. The desk staff treat everyone with such kindness regardless of membership or guest level. Khadeem was especially helpful. Taxis and tours are easily available. Most of the property is wheelchair accessible. Most services are available in English and Spanish.

Good food, very well priced for the Island. I've been here a week and this is the least expensive family dinner we've had. Great family atmosphere and an awesome view of the bay!

I went there for breakfast one day, then lunch another. On both occasions, I received top-notch service. The ambiance is amazing. As you enjoy your delicious meal on the beach, you can take in this breathtaking view of the ocean.

The food was good, but took a LONG time to come out. It also took a long time to get a server to acknowledge our table and get a drink order each time, even when they weren't busy. The drinks were excellent. They include an 18% gratuity on each check, regardless of the size of your party, which is understandable, just good to know ahead of time.

The food was delicious, the service was impeccable, and our room was perfect. We ordered the pasta with chicken, key lime pie, a margarita, The cheeseburger in paradise, and a shrimp dish. We loved the rooftop pool with the swim up bar. The fire show and karaoke nights we fun and inclusive.

We went here for a birthday celebration for my daughter. The service was terrible. We had to ask for everything we needed napkins, refills, etc. Our waitress did not visit our table to check on us. She never asked us if we needed anything, there was no communication. They charge an 18% gratuity on all checks. I have a hard time paying forced gratuity when the service was bad. We won’t eat here again. There are too many other restaurants to eat at on the island where there is friendly, excellent service. Also, their version of Sangria is a plastic cup with red wine and orange slices thrown in there. The food was good, but it’s not worth it when the service is bad. My husband got up a couple of times to get napkins or to find our waitress.

The food was so good! But the prices of the drinks for the size cup you get is ridiculously expensive.

Similar to a chillis food and experience wise, we had a good time and ate here three times over the course of 4 nights. Busier at night, right on the beach you can watch the pelicans dive for fish.

Staff is great and welcoming. Brunch was best and the mimosas perfect 👍🏾 loved Spanish night the best!! Food was deliciously prepared, music was good and what a fun night

This was the BEST food during our vacation. Nearly ate there every day. Our favorite meal of all time was the twisted chicken sandwich, it was so good never got a chance to take a picture

Fun place for a quick drink or even dinner if you had an exhausting snorkeling day like we did. There is a trail from Margaritaville to the bar as well as steps from mirador to the bar. There are even some tarpons to accompany you at your table or eat an extra French fry in case you miss.

This was so much better than margaritaville restaurant. Our waiter was Judy and she was very courteous and recommended us tostones with shredded beef appetizers. Our food came very quickly. We also ordered 2 sandwiches and they were fresh and tasty. We are certainly returning there and want to try breakfast and another dinner. It was a short walk away along the beach from where we were staying at Wyndham Margaritaville. I only recommend wearing flip flops because your feet might get Sandy and wet on the way there.

We just returned from a one-week stay at Margaritaville. We visited Shoreline on our first night there, and returned for lunch, dinner, or just a drink 5 of the 6 nights we were there. Great place! Great staff! Entertaining, flesh eating, giant pet fish :D

Unexpectedly delicious! This was some of the best food we had on our vacation. Service and location were great. Will definitely return.

Had an amazing breakfast here! Was staying at Margaritaville nearby, but walked the beach trail to get over to Shoreline Bar & Grill for a delicious breakfast. It’s a small place but the views are incredible and the food was too. I ordered the crab cake omelette and Bloody Mary. This was one of my most enjoyable meals on the island.

Food was fine. Service was fine. My complaint is that it took an hour to get our food. Simple order: 1 burger and 3 tacos. They weren’t even super busy. No line out the door or anything. Just a normal dinner crowd. Meanwhile we were wrangling our restless 9 month old baby who was getting very hot and agitated. The staff thanked us for our patience at least twice, as other customers who arrived during or after us all got their food, ate, and left before we even got our food. When the manager came to ring up our order I expected him to do something beyond just apologize for the excessively long wait.. such as reduce our charge, give us our chips for free, or a free entree or something. But nope, full price, and 20% tip. They could have at least offered some free drinks during the long, sweaty, mosquito-bitten wait. At least the sunset was nice.

Where they're always glad you came. Good company, great service, quality food, and cold drinks at reasonable prices. The Shoreline was just a 1 minute stroll from our condo door and immediately adjacent to the pool which made it super convenient. The setting is lovely right next to the water (no beach but there are some steps down if you want to swim) with abundant wildlife watching like the famous tarpon, crabs, and I even saw a spotted moray eel! The resident laughing gulls are only a minor nuisance, but they will steal the food right off your plate if you're not paying attention. The next time you're in St. Thomas, head down to the Shoreline and make some new friends. Cheers!

The Shoreline Bar & Grille was the perfect spot to end our nights after exploring the island. Tasty dishes and delicious cocktails. The resturants atmosphere is fun and festive. Excellent customer service from the manager to the kitchen staff. The Shoreline Bar & Grille is situated on the water. You are able to walk eight into the ocean. Bonus is feeding the cute famished tarpons.

We come to St Thomas every year and this place is a local hidden gem. Manny is absolutely amazing. He is one of the only bartenders that will take care of you. He knows how to do his job and is always on top of things. The food is out of this world, especially on theme nights! Breakfast time can be a little slower due to staffing issues but never stops us!

Atmosphere it’s nice, staff is friendly and attentive. Food and drinks are great, we had four different plates and everyone liked theirs. Just a short walk from Margaritaville, highly recommended; good food, drinks and prices!!