My wife and I recently dined at Peters Fine Dining, driven by our appreciation for classic steakhouses such as Caesars in Calgary, Barbarian in downtown Toronto, and Keens in New York City. To our surprise, Peters Fine Dining measured up to these renowned establishments.
Choosing a Tuesday night for our visit, we easily found parking in the back. The captivating old-school decor upon entering immediately caught my eye. Welcomed by numerous hostesses and waiters, we were quickly seated, albeit with a friendly request to remove my hat. One notable critique is the inconsistency in delivering a 'fine dining service.' For instance, being initially led by the bartender rather than the host felt somewhat casual, and our waiter missed the customary introduction. Despite a quiet evening, the absence of a full bar for sitting stood out. Nevertheless, the waitstaff, impeccably dressed in full suits, maintained a commendable level of formality.
Our drink choices, including a martini, negroni, and diet coke, were well-crafted, but the prices—$7 for the coke, $23 for the martini and $21 for the negroni—felt a bit steep. Additionally, the martini could have been chilled more thoroughly, especially for the price.
While the steak menu leaned toward the pricier side, the cost was justified by the quality of the steak, service, and the overall upscale dining experience. Opting for the 16 Oz ribeye cooked medium rare, I relished a perfectly prepared, 45-day-aged delight with well-seasoned vegetables.
We also indulged in the prime rib, accompanied by mashed potatoes and horse radish, along with a complimentary side of garlic bread, albeit slightly overdone. For dessert, we shared a generously portioned, well-caramelized creme brulee.
In summary, Peters Fine Dining positions itself as a higher-priced establishment, justifiable for the quality of its food, though the same can't be said for the drinks. While not flawless, it stands out as a distinctive institution in the northeast GTA, where fine dining options are limited. I would rate this place 4.4/5 stars.